Why Your Will and Other Estate Planning Documents Don’t Belong in a Safe Deposit Box

By Danielle Gardner

A safe deposit box might feel like the best place for your original will. It's fireproof, locked, and out of reach of anyone who shouldn't see it. The trouble is, after you die it's also out of reach of the people who need it.

When you die, the box doesn't open for your family just because they have the key. The bank's rules, state law, and the probate court all stand in the way. The result can be weeks of delay, extra court filings, and added legal fees, all to get the one document that tells the court who should be in charge.

Who can open the box after you die?

If you are the only person on the box, no one can open it without paperwork from the court. A safe deposit box is a rental contract between you and the bank. When you die, the bank freezes access to protect itself until someone proves they have legal authority over your estate.

Having the key doesn't change that. Neither does being named in your will, being your spouse, or being your agent under a power of attorney. A power of attorney ends at death, and so does your agent's authority over the box.

Catch-22: the will is locked in the box

To appoint the personal representative named in your will, the probate court needs the original will. In most cases, a copy won't do. But the bank won't let anyone into the box without court papers, called letters, showing who is in charge. So, the will is locked inside a box that only a court-appointed representative can open.

The fix is a two-step court process:

  1. Ask the court to appoint a special administrator. A family member or other interested person asks the court to appoint someone with limited authority, such as opening the box and delivering the will to the court.

  2. Apply to appoint the personal representative. Once the original will is filed with the court, the person named in it applies to be appointed.

Each step means another filing, another fee, and more time before anyone can pay bills, access accounts, or secure property.

What about your trust, power of attorney, and health care directive?

These documents have a different problem. They're meant to be used while you're alive, often when you can't act for yourself. If they're locked in a box that only you can open, they may be useless at the moment they matter most.

  1. Health care directive. Doctors and hospitals may need it in an emergency, sometimes within hours. Your health care agent can't wait for the bank to open on Monday and may not be allowed into your box at all.

  2. Durable power of attorney. If you become incapacitated, your agent needs this document to deal with banks, insurers, government agencies, and others. If it's in your box and your agent doesn't have a copy, they may have no way to get it.

  3. Revocable trust. Your successor trustee needs the trust document to step in if you become incapacitated or die. A trust usually avoids probate, but not if the trustee has to go to court just to get the document.

If you do keep these originals in a box, make sure the people you named can get to them, both now and upon your death. The simplest way is to add a trusted person to the box as a co-renter. That only helps if they're alive and able to open the box when the time comes. A co-renter can also open the box at any time, which carries its own risks.

Better places to keep your originals

If a safe deposit box is a risky place for your will and other estate planning documents, where should you keep them? The best spot is safe from fire and theft but can be reached by the right person without a court order.

  • A fireproof safe at home. Make sure your personal representative or a trusted family member knows where it is and how to open it.

  • With the probate court, in some states. Some states let you deposit your will with the court for safekeeping during your life. Alaska and Ohio probate courts allow this for a small fee. Utah and Idaho law currently don't.

  • Idaho's will registry. Idaho residents can record where their will is kept with the Secretary of State for a small fee, so family knows where to find it later. The registry doesn't hold the will itself.

Wherever you keep them, give copies of your power of attorney and health care directive to your agents and your doctor. Leave a short note with your important papers saying where each original is.

The bottom line

A safe deposit box is a fine place for precious metals, jewelry, coins, and titles. It's not the best place for the documents your family will need first.

If your estate planning documents are in a safe deposit box, consider moving them. If you choose to keep them in a safety deposit box, think about whether anyone on the box will realistically be able to open the box when they're needed.

This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state and change over time. Talk with an attorney about your situation.

Next
Next

Estate Planning Lessons from Harry Potter: When No Guardian is Chosen